FetalPlus vs Elvie vs Willow vs Momcozy - Best Wearable Breast Pumps Reviewed - 2024 Updates
Emily Copley
Lead Maternity Carer/Registered Nurse & Midwife
Updated 21st Dec, 2023
In my 10 years of experience as a midwife, I’ve found a breast pump an indispensable tool that can bring an enormous sense of relief to a nursing mother’s life — especially for working mothers or those with multiples. It can make motherhood less daunting and more joyful.
In this review guide, I will show you my favorite breast pump that I’ve recommended to thousands of new parents. I will also give you other breast pump options that are decent alternatives to my favorite. Further, you will learn all the vital information about a breast pump that will help you determine which pump is suitable for your needs.
Review for Moms promise to pay for every product we review 100% with our own funds and not taking anything from manufacturer so we are consistent in delivering the most transparent, reliable and unbiased information of the products for every mum. It’s a consortium of field experts and first-hand users of a myriad of products bringing you cutting-edge reviews aimed at helping you make fact-driven educated decisions.
RANKED # 1
FetalPlus 3.0 Wearable Breast Pump
FetalPlus is one of the strongest, most reliable, and most affordable brands for new mothers. They’re pioneering a range of smart products for mothers and children that are efficient and do not break the bank. Their wearable electric breast pump is the one product I recommend the most to my patients who are expecting or just delivered. Why? Because it is the only pump I’ve found that’s powerful enough to express milk in a short amount of time while costing a fraction of most other wearable breast pumps of the same caliber.
- No cords or tubes, 100% hands-free: Weighs just 0.5 lb, its small size makes it very easy to insert into a bra cup. Because this model is without any cords or tubes, it’s hardly noticeable under clothes and will not limit your movement as you go about your day.
-
Comfortable pumping for every mom : It has three modes — pumping mode, massage mode, and mix mode. Each mode has 9 suction levels to simulate the baby's natural suckling rhythm. All the different modes and levels are catered to create a comfortable pumping experience for all nursing moms, especially those who need extra stimulation to express milk.
- Powerful Suction: It provides a maximum suction level of 280 mmHg which is the best of class. This also means pumping takes shorter. Auctually, most moms I know tell me they never had to put the suction level over 4 or 5 (the max is 9)
- Soft touch with silicone shields and inserts : Unlike many other breast pumps, all parts of the FetalPlus 3.0 wearable breast pump that touch your skin are made of soft silicone. This is one of the most noticeable differences that significantly increase comfort when pumping.
- Portable & Rechargable: This device comes with a rechargeable 1200 mah high-capacity battery. It should last you 3 hours on a full charge which is ideal for at least 6 sessions. Since it’s rechargeable, this pump is perfect for on-the-go moms who are limited on time and cannot stay stationary in a spot while pumping.
- Anti-backflow & leak-proof technology: This pump’s intelligent design keeps the milk isolated from other pump pieces. This cements hygiene by ensuring the milk stays pure. Its no-spill technology also prevents leakage incidents if you’re pumping in the correct posture.
- Bright display screen and touch panel
- BPA-free. Dishwasher safe. Easy to clean.
- US based. Free Shipping Available
- Accepts HSA/FSA Funds
- Shop Now, Pay Later with Sezzle
- Not APP Controlled: This pump is relatively straight forward, all controls are thourgh the touch panel where you can seamlessly operate with just a finger.
9.2
Our No.1 Pick
Value For Money
Suction Power & Speed
Ease-of-use
Comfortableness
Battery Life
Noise Level
Discount Code:
Use discount code X30 to get a further $30 OFF your purchase.
RANKED # 2
Elvie Pump
Its sleek, ergonomic designs make it a pleasure to carry around. Like the other hands-free breast pump on this list, the Elvie pump is compact and sits directly on your breast. It is cordless and completely hands-free.
The Elvie Pump is expensive. A single unit will cost you $299.99, and if you’re looking for double pumps, be ready to pay $549.99. While Elvie Pump is aesthetically stunning, its performance and features are not enough to justify the high price. You can always purchase one pump, but be aware that you’ll have to wait 60 minutes before using it on the other breast. This broad wait time can be frustrating for many mothers.
- Noice Levels: It is quiet but, again, not completely silent. You will be able to hear the faint sound of suction and the milk dripping into the container. But the noise isn’t noticeable if you’re in a crowded and busy space or outside.
- Stylish Design: Its all-in-one design ensures that the entire working parts of the pump are situated inside it. The whole unit can be neatly tucked into your nursing bra for a hands-free experience.
- Closed system for hygienic pumping: Since this unit is a closed system, the milk stays separate from the pump mechanism and keeps its purity. The whole unit is also BPA-free and completely safe for the baby and the mother.
- APP controlled
- Accepts HSA/FSA Funds
- It is costly: A single unit will cost you $299.99, and if you’re looking for double pumps, be ready to pay $549.99. While Elvie Pump is aesthetically stunning, its performance and features are just not enough to justify the price.
- Leaking issues: Many moms complain that they faced leaky issues with the Elvie.
- Lower Suction Power: Expect to get about 220 mmHG suction intensity on its highest setting which is much lower than FetalPlus. Its suction prowess is nothing to boast about but it may get the job done for mothers who have an easy time expressing milk without strong suction.
8.4
Our No.2 Pick
Value For Money
Suction Power & Speed
Ease-of-use
Comfortableness
Battery Life
Noise Level
#3
Willow Go’s compact, unobstructed design ensures that it sits neatly inside the bra and stays hidden as you go about your day, walking, cleaning after your little one, cooking, or rocking your baby to sleep. This device is relatively noise-free on low suction levels. But, once you move past level 6 to a higher suction level, you will notice the operation to be loud. This unit will cost you $329, which is significantly more pricey than FetalPlus’ wearable breast pump, which offers the same suction capability.
- APP controlled
- Two flange sizes: The Willow Go comes with 21mm and 24mm flanges, which is one more compared to the FetalPlus. Other flange sizes cost $19.99 each.
- Decent Suction Power: The Willow Go offers a max suction intensity of 280 mmHg. Also with 9 levels to select from.
- Accepts HSA/FSA Funds
- Hefty price tag: At $329, the Willow Go doesn't offer strong enough functions to justify the price tag.
- Shorter battery life: Lasts up to only 3 sessions of pumping in a full charge.
8.2
Our #3 Pick
Value For Money
Suction Power & Speed
Ease-of-use
Comfortableness
Battery Life
Noise Level
#4
The Momcozy S12 Pro is a wearable breast pump that allows moms to pump milk discreetly and hands-free. This breast pump comes with a rechargeable battery and has multiple suction levels and massage modes. However, some moms have reported that the pump is noisy and that the suction could be stronger. Compared to the FetalPlus 3.0, the S12 Pro has fewer suction levels and massage modes, as well as a less affordable price point.
- Adjustable suction levels and massage mode
- Lightweight and discreet design: The pump is also lightweight and relatively portable.
- Comes with a carrying bag and two sizes of flanges
- Difficult to put together and clean: Some moms reported the S12 Pro takes 10-15 mins everytime to put together because of its design.
- Shorter battery life: Lasts up to only 5-6 sessions of pumping in a full charge.
8.1
Our #4 Pick
Value For Money
Suction Power & Speed
Ease-of-use
Comfortableness
Battery Life
Noise Level
Why FetalPlus 3.0 Wearable Breast Pump is my favorite?
The FetalPlus 3.0 wearable electric breast pump is the one product I recommend the most to my patients who are expecting or just delivered. Why? Because it is the only pump I’ve found that’s powerful enough to express milk in a short amount of time while costing a fraction of most other pumps.
The battery is quite long-lasting, and most mothers use it during the day and charge it overnight for the next day’s use. You can use it while doing the dishes, taking care of a high-energy toddler, cleaning, and other errands. When not in use, just pop everything in the convenient drawstring bag it comes with and take it anywhere with you.
I would not ignore the money factor when giving product recommendations. This pump is affordably priced at $129 for a pair, which is significantly cheaper than similar models in the market today (most will cost you double or triple this amount for just one pump). I recommend purchasing a pair to pump both breasts simultaneously.
The FetalPlus 3.0 Wearable Breast Pump provides a maximum suction level of 280 mmHg which is the best of class. This means each pumping session takes shorter. Auctually, most moms I know tell me they never had to put the suction level over 4 or 5 (the max is 9)
My Final Verdict
Fetalplus 3.0 Wearable Breast Pump is my No.1 choice. The reason is simple, this is a powerful, hands-free, straightforward breast pump that gets the job done nicely, and costs not even a third the price of other popular pumps.
Discounts: Fetalplus currently has a discount code X30 to get $30 OFF your purchase. Check to see if the promo is still available.